Not All Guilt is Created Equally

Not all guilt is created equally.

With my close family and friends, I’m a fixer. A peacemaker. I want everyone and everything to be OK at all times. For a long time, I’ve felt like it was my responsibility to make others happy—and when they weren’t, I felt it in my body. A kind of visceral uneasiness, like something is off and it must be my fault.

So, I’d look for how to fix it.

How to smooth it over.

How to put the smile back on their face . . . even if it meant changing myself in the process.

And here’s the honest part:

That instinct? It serves me really well as your coach. I help you investigate, reflect, and look at your choices with intention. I sit with you in the hard moments and help you find your way forward.

But in my personal life, unchecked, that same instinct can quickly turn into over-responsibility.

Because not all guilt is created equal.

Healthy guilt is aligned with your values. It shows up when you’ve acted in a way that doesn’t quite match who you want to be. It’s constructive. It says, “Hey, let’s clean that up.” It leads to repair, growth, and forward movement.

But toxic guilt?

That’s the kind that convinces you you’re responsible for things that were never yours to carry.

Someone else’s disappointment.

Someone else’s reaction.

Someone else’s unmet expectations.

It whispers:

• “You should have handled that better.”

• “You made them feel that way.”

• “It’s your job to keep the peace.”

  
  

And it often shows up in the moment someone shares how they feel.

Instead of hearing them, you feel it land as: “I did something wrong.” So, you jump in—defending, explaining, fixing—before you’ve even fully listened.

But here’s the shift:

Someone expressing their feelings is not the same thing as accusing you.

You don’t have to take it personally to take it seriously.

You can pause. You can listen. You can let their experience exist. . . without making it mean something about your worth.

And you can still hold your ground.

Because this is also true:

It is not your job to regulate someone else’s feelings.

You can be kind. You can be thoughtful. You can communicate clearly and with care.

But you are not responsible for how someone else chooses to process, react, or respond.

That’s where boundaries come in—not as walls, but as clarity.

In this season of my life, I need this reminder often. How can you apply this to your own life?

Journal Prompts:

• When do I feel the strongest urge to “fix” someone else’s emotions? What does that feel like in my body?

• What am I afraid might happen if I don’t step in to make things better?

• Where did I learn that other people’s feelings are my responsibility?

• When I take something personally, what story do I immediately tell myself?

• What would it look like to listen बिना defending, explaining, or fixing?

• Where is guilt helping me grow… and where is it keeping me stuck?

• What is one boundary I’ve been avoiding, and what feels hard about setting it?

• How can I show care for someone else without abandoning myself?

Affirmations:

• I can care deeply without carrying what isn’t mine.

• I am allowed to listen without defending myself.

• Someone else’s feelings do not define me.

• I release the need to fix everything and everyone.

---

Office Hours:  No more Office Hours in April. This is for Editor's Circle Coaching Members as well as any Guided Revision Coaching Members who would like to touch base between scheduled coaching appointments. HERE is the link to schedule a 30-minute slot

The Weekly Draft: happens every Sunday evening at 7pm at this link. Come prepared to reflect on the past week and draft the upcoming week. It is meant to be a heads down, co-planning time, with me being available to share strategies and/or answer questions. Join me HERE